With so many options for treating alkalinity, it is hard to know which one truly works the best. There are three main options that are typically represented in the marketplace for Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTP) when faced with this question: magnesium hydroxide, lime slurry, and caustic soda. The following outlines the good and the bad of each, hopefully providing needed guidance for decision making at WWTPs.
Most wastewater treatment plant operators understand that their wastewater treatment plants function best at some ideal pH and that a minimum amount of alkalinity is required to keep microorganisms happy. But too often, the values of pH and alkalinity are incorrectly used interchangeably, and a thorough understanding of each parameter’s true relationship to biological stability and optimal performance – gets lost in the translation.
Most often, this error in terminology stems from the use of the most common alkaline pH modifiers and alkalinity supplements, caustic soda and lime.Where their use may successfully meet pH demands, they will likely fall short in supplying adequate alkalinity requirements without adversely elevating pH beyond biologically healthy limits. Furthermore, maintaining pH stability and uniformity across entire treatment basins remains a virtual impossibility. Therefore, it’s important to look at each option for pH & alkalinity adjustments and ensure a good understanding of the effects of each on the system For example, when looking at nitrification process alone, it has been reported that having a stable, slightly elevate
d pH and enough alkalinity can drastically improve the denitrification of wastewater (see figure).
Hydrated Lime Slurry:
A very common product, also known as hydrated lime or CaO quicklime, lime can be ‘slurry-ized’ through the addition of water to dry lime powder. This slurry can be used to treat wastewater to increase pH and alkalinity and is commonly used in potable water to “soften,” or remove hardness minerals, such as calcium and magnesium from drinking water.
Lime slurries minimize the effects of potential scaling in the water distribution system. It is also the most commonly used product to maintain alkalinity levels because of its low cost and multiple treatment benefits, such as assisting in the removal of manganese and iron from water.
The downside of lime slurry originates from its high solubility. Maintaining proper pH levels often becomes biologically prohibitive before ideal alkalinity levels and process stability can be reached. Another major concern is lime slurry will cause an increase in waste sludge, sometimes as much as 50% – adding more disposal costs to the operation. If that wasn’t already enough, hydrated lime slurry added in collection systems increases the operations and maintenance costs related to formation of scale and accumulated solids/sludge. In severe cases this can lead to line blockages.
Caustic Soda is commonly referred to Sodium Hydroxide or NaOH. Surprisingly, it can be commonly found in the home but in the industrial sense, it is mainly used for alkaline neutralization. Caustic Soda is found in all kinds of concentrations and is a common, popular way to neutralize and tame all kinds of acids. It is also considered easy to introduce to the system due to its solubility. However, at high concentrations, it is extremely hazardous to handle and several precautious must be in place to safely use in the treatment process. These would include enhanced PPE (personal protective equipment) and immediately accessible wash stations at a minimum.
Similar to Lime Slurry, because of the high solubility of Caustic Soda, pH often becomes biologically prohibitive very quickly. This often results in an increased risk of burning (elevated pH) out the microbiology before you can make adjustments. Additionally, the relationship between temperature and percentage of caustic in the solution is also important to pay attention to – above 50% concentration, the freeze point is 60°F restricting its use to warm climates or requiring heating tanks. Using lower percentage Caustic soda reduces the freezing point and diminishes some of these concerns, but you will need to pay more in freight to ship ‘the water’ content of the blend – ultimately a higher cost. Lastly, it is generally the most expensive of the three options discussed depending on current market value and delivery locations, especially when you take into account the relative dosage and alkalinity delivered per pound of product as discussed later.
Magnesium Hydroxide is also referred to as milk of magnesia and the main function of the product is to neutralize the acids and stabilize alkalinity. Magnesium Hydroxide is generally worry free for alkalinity adjustments due to its self-buffering nature. Magnesium Hydroxide will only solubilize and generate a pH up to around 8.5, rendering this chemical safe to use because the likelihood of burning out (pH above 9) the biological activity is nearly impossible.
Magnesium Hydroxide does have some drawbacks. The slurry (typically 60-66%) separates and therefore must constantly be mixed or circulated. This issue can be readily solved and worry free through proper equipment selection to prevent this from happening. While Magnesium Hydroxide is the most difficult to store out of the three options presented, the benefits of alkalinity and pH stability will result in more consistent reaction times and with its self-buffering properties, will maintain more stable environments for wastewater treatment biological organisms to work as efficiently as possible – without killing them.
How Much Do You Need to Use?
Caustic Soda and Lime Slurry are definitely go to chemistries for the WWTP industry and they do provide the needed pH adjustments required. But on a pound to pound basis there is a fundamental difference between those two and magnesium hydroxide to also consider that does not have much to do with pH or alkalinity, but rather the true amount required to treat. For example, a given water sample may require 100 mg/L of magnesium hydroxide to raise the pH to 8.8. For the same sample, 138 mg/L of caustic soda and 135 mg/L of lime would be required.
THE BOTTOM LINE EXAMPLE: